Community Stories

-Public money should be spent on and for the public and should reflect community values.-

Every one of our community members has a story to tell. We were amazed at the variety and wisdom of community responses to the survey. We asked a few Alamedans to tell us their personal stories to highlight how their lived experiences are connected to the priorities represented in the ACB survey. They spoke to Basic Needs, Community, and Public Safety issues here in Alameda. Their stories include vibrant ideas for making Alameda a healthier and stronger community. 

Jayden’s Story

“My name is Jayden. I’m 19. Growing up, I loved watching sports and playing basketball. When you grow up (as I did) around an environment that you know doesn't love you, through time, you build this character where you just love yourself, and you wanna make sure your family and the ones you love are okay no matter the situation. And we [at the Point] host a lot of community events: baseball games, car shows, special events. So in a way, we've helped out, and all we want back is just to be helped out.” 

Basic Needs 

“My mom used to get a lot of food stamps. I would buy all the snacks, even a bag of chips for someone I may not know, but I know them through my little siblings. It's like a relief, like a relief of joy. I help someone else, like the best feeling ever.” 

“Sometimes the choice is what can you afford to plug in–a refrigerator? The microwave? We couldn't use the stove, so we had to use the microwave. But also, we're not financially stable to buy stuff to use for the microwave.” 

Question 4. Out of 326 responses, 175 (53.68%) said that “Health Services, such as outreach, basic care, on-demand mental health and wellness services, and wellness education” is “Extremely Important” to them. 

“The sharp turnover [of supportive staff] is hard. People are wanting that counseling and support and when someone you've gotten close to leaves, it's hard to reignite that bond. It's like you're breaking your bond to make a new one. It's only so many times you could break bonds and keep making new ones to the point you don't want to make bonds anymore.”

“I would like to see the base provide for the people, not just for temporary moments. If the base was to hire maybe five counselors. Every day, they meet with at least three kids, 45 to 50 kids each week, just someone there knowing that they care about you.” 

“I would provide free rehab for people who needed, or maybe just one-on-one counseling with every individual on the base, just something to start the recognition that the Alameda Point needs a helping hand.” 

“One thing they should change is [having] washing machines free. Why if you know people are low income why would you make them pay? $5 dollars, every time to wash clothes. That five could go to buy food, rent, electricity.” 

“Help people get their IDs. Help people get their license. I would like to see a job fair on the base. One that offers jobs right now, not months down the road, jobs that will hire you even when you have a felony on your record. Jobs that recognize the skills people have like being good at fixing cars.” 

“The base used to do breakfast every weekend for the community. They stopped doing that. And that was a way for the community to talk to each other. I feel like every week there should be a day or two where they serve free lunch for the kids. You know, even if it's a school day, even if it's summer.” 

Community 

Question 12. Out of 323 responses, 154 (47.68%) said that “Parks and Recreation, such as maintaining parks and pools, community events, and promoting environmental education and stewardship” was “Extremely Important.” 

“So my friends and stuff, we are beginning to be at a point where it is like happiness just isn't there no more, that drive to go. Let's go play basketball, at what court? The court, demolished. They did not think to fix the only basketball court that the base had. So that went away.” 

“Families go to the education center, asking to have the rest of the milk, asking to have the rest of the snacks, asking to have the rest of what they need in their household and the education center is a place where you can go to ask for stuff like that. But when the education center isn't being supported with [what it] needs to provide, what do we do?” 

Question 11. Out of 323 responses, 155 people (47.99%) said “Housing Affordability, such as first-time homebuyer support, social housing, protecting tenants from displacement, flexible housing assistance, and supportive housing” is “Extremely Important.”

“We went over to [the neighbor’s to] sing “Happy Birthday.” We heard a loud “boom, boom, boom.” Someone opened the door and came in. It was her property manager saying that there's too many guests in this house. Just because they are property management does not give them the okay just to barge in your house? And it's happened numerous times.” 

“They used to have these pop up inspections when they come in the house, just to make sure it's clean. When you live in a house with seven kids, four of the kids under the age of five, how do you expect the house not to get messy? Knowing that you guys are just gonna show up yet again? Without knocking, they came right in. My mom was in the shower. I was in my room, you know, everyone was kind of doing their thing. No one knew they were actually in the house, until my mom, with her towel around her, went to the living room to grab something. She needed to get dressed, to only be addressed by the property management. “Wow, what are you guys doing here?” They are over here saying, “We don’t have to let you know.” 

Question 8. Out of 323 responses, 153 (47.37%) said that “Child and Youth Development, such as after-school programs, neighborhood youth programs, and youth centers” is “Extremely Important.” 

“Let's not forget that our children would also like to play at nice parks. Our children also would like to have fundraisers with food and stuff. Because I know a lot of kids, personally, I go to sleep hungry. I know a lot of kids personally that come outside with no shoes on. What would help? [Clothing drives], as in jacket shirts, sweat socks, underwear needs, shampoo, conditioner, everything.” 

“I will be at Park and Rec Centers and see what snacks and treats they have. And I have a picture in my head of what the kids on the base have been given. There's been numerous times where whole batches were expired milk and sandwiches that were super hard you'd throw on the grounds and it would sound like a rock, but the Rec Centers, nicely made peanut butter jelly sandwiches, nicely made desserts.” 

Question 5. Out of 326 responses, 165 people (50.61%) reported that “Maintaining Infrastructure, such as streets, sidewalks, bike lanes, beaches, public landscaping, and sewer” is “Extremely Important.” 

“Maintenance is needed badly! Every time I shower at my mom's house I break out in rashes, my body itches. What could it possibly be? Because I know I am not the only one going through it.”

“When the whole base, all of our water shut down, we had to shower in these little boxes that they literally put at the end of the base, so we would have to walk there. Knowingly. No one has cars, no one has a license.” 

“When you go anywhere else in Alameda you see signs where kids are at play. “Caution, 25 mph.” You go anywhere on the base, you don't see signs that say, "Kids at play.” Kids are right here! No speed limit. No speed bumps. It's like they completely forgot about the kids of the base. With kids, my siblings, a regular day for them is waking up not wanting to play at the park, because the infrastructure, the mess, the smell, the used needles, the wrappers, the garbage, you know, there's no place for a kid when it's like that. There's actually been an incident where there were prescription pills at the park, a kid thought it was candy and went ahead and ate them, luckily, the kid’s fine.” 

Public Safety 

“One time we called the police when our garage had been broken into, only for them to detain my mom over a warrant that she had already settled. Knowing that the cop knew that she settled. They detained her. I was crying. My sisters were crying, because who wants to see their mother in handcuffs? Another lesson for the police, which should be number one, if there's kids around, it's have a little bit more respect.” 

Question 17. Out of 316 responses, 64 people (20.25%) shared that the “Police Department, such as staff, vehicles, surveillance equipment, and weapons” was “Extremely Important” to them( the lowest level recorded). 

“Where I grew up, there were always a lot of cop cars around. What do I want? For kids not to grow up seeing SWAT teams break into a house and all the kids watching, being scared of the police when they come around.” 

“You know, my siblings are traumatized because we had an incident where SWAT came in knowing there was kids in the house and still drawing their weapons. And I remember that day clearly, and I felt like there was no remorse. I feel like there was no heart in the cops that did that because there was no calm talking, if that makes sense. Yes, I know my father hasn't been on the right track, but he still doesn't deserve to be slammed, choked, kneed on the head.” 

“Just the other day, we had an incident where guns were drawn on my friend’s black father. I remember the exact day, and guns were drawn instantly and in my opinion, and I'm speaking for everyone who was there, including my friends, the guns were drawn because he was black.”


Lauren’s Story

“I’m Lauren. I’ve lived in Alameda for 20 years. I’ve worked within Community Action for a Sustainable Alameda (CASA) to advance the City’s Climate Action and Resiliency Plan (CARP), the climate emergency declaration, climate mitigation plans, and emergency operations plans. Having served as an environmental planner with the two major Bay Area port authorities, I have managed numerous sea level rise mitigation projects and climate adaptation and resiliency efforts.” 

Why is sea level rise adaptation important to you? 

“I love living in Alameda. I love the fact that it's an island with waterside access. I’m a professional mariner, I teach sailing at Club Nautique and I coach sailing for yacht clubs and private boat owners. Many islanders live here because of the access to the Bay. The island’s waterfront development and infrastructure will be compromised as a result of sea level rise. I live in Marina Village and use the local waterfront parks and marinas daily. Being able to have safe and easy pedestrian and bike access to waterfront areas and all island parks is important to me personally and to my family and friends as well.” 

Question 6. Out of 326 responses, 270 (82.9%) said that “City Planning, such as transit and transportation options, parking, climate adaptation, and renovating buildings to be climate-resilient, safe, and healthy.” is “Extremely or Very Important” to them. 

What has Alameda done so far to address climate change? 

“The City of Alameda has been really proactive locally and regionally in planning and preparing for climate change. The City council adopted a Climate Emergency declaration. The Climate Emergency Declaration set the ambitious goal of achieving carbon neutrality by 2030. Alameda Municipal Power (AMP) laid a strong foundation for building decarbonization by providing 100% clean, carbon free electricity since 2020. Currently, 70% of Alameda's greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions come from transportation, 27% from natural gas use in buildings, and three percent (3%) from other sources such as waste, water, and wastewater. 

“In 2019, the City adopted a revised carp, with some lofty goals related to reductions in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The goal is to be below 50% of 2005 levels of greenhouse gas emissions. The CARP plans to reach these goals through equitable improvements to transit, building, and waste management. The plan identifies dozens of measures to reduce GHG emissions and adapt to climate change challenges such as heat, drought, fire, sea level rise and flooding. 

“In 2022, the City adopted a CARP update entitled “Climate Adaptation and Hazard Mitigation Plan” which describes the natural and climate hazards that impact Alameda's people, buildings, businesses and assets, identifies our vulnerability to those hazards, and describes actions to reduce our risk from these hazards. This plan addresses the hazards of earthquakes, floods, sea level/groundwater rise, tsunamis, heat, smoky air, drought, and dam failure inundation. 

“As a result of adopting the CARP, the City has been very successful in acquiring grants for priority sea level rise adaptations projects. The City of Alameda, the City of Oakland and the Port of Oakland have formed an adaptation working group for San Leandro Bay. Four major adaptation projects have received funding and are about to commence. These projects include: San Leandro Bay/Oakland-Alameda Estuary, Northern Shoreline near Posey/Webster Tubes, Veterans Court, and Doolittle Drive/State Route 61. 

“In addition, the City has performed numerous vulnerability and risk assessment studies to identify flooding hazards and vulnerable populations.” 

How is Alameda addressing Emergency Preparedness? 

“The City Fire Department has a vibrant Community Emergency Response Team (CERT) program which provides training to Alameda residents and employees of Alameda businesses to help increase self-sufficiency in the event of a disaster. Participants learn skills that will enable them to provide emergency assistance to their families and neighbors. 

“The CARP was done in tandem with City updates to the Emergency Operations Plan and the 2040 General Plan. All these plans identify vulnerabilities, hazards, and specific things to prepare Alameda for emergencies and disaster response. These plans also identify responsible agencies, coordinated responses and opportunities for funding and resources. There has been lots of coordination on the City’s part with different stakeholders within the City and efforts to be in sync and align with each other. All of this has helped with opportunities for funding.” 

“Alameda is lucky in some sense because the City is home to the Water and Emergency Transit Agency maintenance and operations center along with the Navy and several big marine contractors and construction companies at Alameda Point that can help with logistics and emergency response scenarios.” 

Question 18. Out of 315 responses, 257 (81.6%) said that “Emergency and Disaster Preparedness and Planning, such as earthquake, climate, and other disaster education and response.” is “Extremely or Very Important” to them. 

What else would you like to see happen moving forward? 

“One really great first step would be: start planning for and designing resilience hubs. The City’s emergency response manager is looking to create resilience hubs. There is lots of funding out there to support resilience hubs, we just need to find the right locations on island. 

“The City itself needs more staffing and resources to adequately implement these great resiliency plans. They need more funding to adequately implement projects for priority vulnerable areas. Local community based organizations like CASA also need funding and resources to help spread the word. Most importantly, we need to be getting the message out to residents about the SEVERE pending emergency we’re facing, and what the potential risks and vulnerabilities are. Community members need to know what they can do as individuals and support city investments in adaptation solutions. There’s a big disconnect between what the city is doing and what residents understand the city is doing. Also, local businesses should get engaged by helping fund solutions, and supporting waste reduction, energy conservation and transit access. 

“Folks should be grateful we are where we are with plans and projects. We’re farther ahead than most municipalities. What we need to do now is embrace that momentum, get our community behind all of this, including individual residents and businesses.”


Sarah’s story

“I’m Sarah and I’ve lived in Alameda since  2001. I’m a single mom and public high school teacher in Alameda. My son is now 21 and in college. I raised him here on a single income.  I also grew up in Alameda, class of 1988, so I went away and then came back to raise my family. When I grew up in Alameda it was a working class, Navy town, and a family could buy a house on a school teacher’s salary. Those days are gone.

What is the state of housing affordability in Alameda?

“It’s shocking to me how expensive it is, especially being a teacher. I’m 20 years into teaching, and to rent a one bedroom apartment in Alameda for $2,000, is more than a third of my monthly take home pay. And I feel like it just gets siphoned off into somebody else’s pocket. I feel like it’s too much.”

Question 11. Out of 323 respondents, 240 said that housing affordability was extremely or very important to them.

“[In] my previous place, I moved in and there was a gas leak, there were two drains that didn’t work, there was a black mold problem, and all of this came up within my first two months of living in this place. And then I felt  angry at Alameda’s rental agencies.. They vet out prospective tenants  for the landlords. They check  all your finances, they check your credit report, they do all of that for the landlord, but they don’t vet anything for the prospective tenant. And the tenant has to pay them a fee!   For the fee I paid to Cerda Zein, I should’ve  been  guaranteed that there was not a gas leak, that the drains were  draining, that there wasn’t  a black mold problem. And also I feel like black mold should be reported, if that’s a situation in any place.”   

“Also, every tenant pays a deposit. So, if a landlord has a place with ten units and each unit has a $2,000 deposit, that’s $20,000. Where’s the interest? [...] What are the landlords doing with all of these deposits that they’re just hanging onto? That’s money in the bank for them, that’s interest that they’re earning on my money.  I believe that tenants should receive an annual dividend check for the interest earned on our rental deposits.”

“As a school teacher, I can tell you the moment I saw the housing change. [My] students had been living in apartments that cost $700. They would get a note from their landlord that basically, the  next month, it’s going to be $1,200, and the month after  it’s going to be $1,600. So they’re priced out and they’re moving. And it happened at the same time that I noticed all of these unmarked tour buses in town. I’m like,” I’ve never seen these before”. I’m like, “what are these unmarked tour buses doing here?” And at the same time, I’m noticing, my students, especially my really economically challenged students’ families, are having to leave. The rents are suddenly going up. There was no protection at that point.” [These were private buses to bring Alameda employees to Silicon Valley workplaces such as Google. The buses had wifi and made the commute easy. Suddenly Alameda was discovered by many people with six figure incomes. Another change is that apartment complexes started to be bought up by corporations with out-of-state stockholders. This made it more of a ruthless for-profit situation, rather than the  long-time mom-and-pop landlords who lived locally and had a stake in our community.  Rents doubled over a two year period and there was an exodus of lower-income families. ] 

Question 2. Out of 326 respondents, 236 considered housing security extremely or very important. 

“So, now my son is going to college and I want to give him a leg up in the world, so I downsized even more and am renting a room in a house. And it’s a wonderful room, it’s as big as a small studio and I have my own bathroom. It’s not the end of the world, but It’s not where I thought I’d be at 53. And it’s a  sacrifice because I want my son to go to college and start his life, and yet, you know,  it’s not as much as  I thought I could do on a teacher’s salary in a lifetime. I felt a lot of freedom moving into this shared house with two housemates (also in their 50’s). It’s $1,200 and it freed up $800 [that] can help my son out. To help pay for college and a car, just the basic things that it’s nice for a 21 year old starting off in life to have.  It felt like I was freeing myself from the capitalist structure in a way, to do this. But you know, I miss having a garden. I miss having a space where I can just have my friends come and gather. My housemates are super cool, but I also feel like this is a temporary situation.”

What can be done to improve housing affordability in Alameda? 

“I just feel that the city could be more creative. Here would be my question for the city council now that they’ve approved  and built a massive amount of new million dollar condos:   Who is tracking the data?   At city council meetings some years  ago, council members  made big promises that all this new housing was going to bring rental costs down– it was a big vision of trickle down housing that would make housing in Alameda more affordable. So, are they tracking that? And can they show that, as they want to build even more  in Alameda, which actually affects our quality of life, can they show that all this building of houses has created more affordable housing? I’m not seeing it. Can they prove to the community with data driven analysis that the building of all these new million dollar condos has brought down the rents? I’m sure the developers made a fortune while our community has lost our working marinas and lightly trafficked streets. Can they prove to Alameda residents that this has not just been another example of privatized gain and socialized loss? Was it worth it? Where is all the affordable housing they promised would come?

“[One idea of a solution] would be for the city to help with down payments. To offer a down payment program, possibly use a local credit union to help get down payments for people.”

“Another  idea would be to look into co-housing ownership structures, where you could own a home or apartment building  together. If the city is looking for ideas of how they can help people, they can start a program or give some incentives to people where you get five people together buying a big house, owning it together, and then that way creating some wealth over time through investment.”

“Another positive move would be to incentivize local ownership of apartment buildings and dis-incentivize corporate ownership.   Corporations have a legal mandate to their shareholders to earn as much profit as possible, thereby maximizing rents,  where local landlords have the flexibility to prioritize people and community. (My current landlord is a long-time Alameda  family and they keep our rent below market and still make a good profit for themselves.) Landlords can be naturally caring, good people, but corporations are not people, they have no souls.”

“I’m different in that I'm not for all the development. One thing that bothers me is that  many vocal Alamedans on Peeps and other social media platforms paint a picture that it’s  the renters versus the people who don’t want development. I feel like I’m both of those things because I do like Alameda with lightly trafficked streets. I ride my bike to work every day. I love all the trees and the parks and the small schools sprinkled around town.  I feel that the Alameda city council has been using the whole pro-renter smoke and mirrors thing in order to build and build and build and build and that that has actually been a profit motive, power motive, with the sugar coating of ‘we are for affordable housing.’ So therefore I think the tracking [of] the data is really important. And opening up the conversation. And not saying that all the people who want slow growth are anti-renter. Because  I’m both of those things right now.”